Secret Reaper Gift Tags

A Secret Reaper gift should not give the giver away. Every tag on this sheet signs off as “Your Reaper” so the name stays hidden until the unmasking. Run the exchange itself with our Secret Reaper gift exchange guide.

What’s Included

• 12 tags on one letter sheet, each 2 x 3.5 inches with a punch ring at the top
• A “To:” line and a “From: Your Reaper” line on every gift tag
• Ten messages: “Your Name Was Drawn”, “Collected by the Reaper”, “Do Not Open Until the Witching Hour”, “Marked by the Reaper”, “A Gift from Beyond the Veil”, “Signed, Sealed, Reaped”, “Your Reaper Has Come for You”, “Open at Your Own Risk”, “No One Escapes the Reaper” and “Your Secret Is Safe Until the Unmasking”
• Two kitchen tags (“From the Reaper’s Kitchen” and “Baked Beyond the Grave”) that read “Made in a home kitchen” with two Contains lines and a Made on date
• A dark version in gold on black, and a print version in black on white that saves ink

Using the Kitchen Tags

Fill in the Contains line even for candy. FARE warns that “candy that comes in ‘mini’ sizes may have different ingredients than its larger counterparts” and that “candy corn often contains egg whites” (FARE). Copy the ingredients from the label of the bag you actually bought, and check them against your recipient’s allergy boxes on the sign-up sheet. The Made on date tells them how long the food has been out of the oven.

Print on cardstock, cut on the dashed lines and punch the ring. A tag tied outside the box gets scuffed in the mail, so tie it to the gift inside.

Pairs With

• Secret Reaper Sign-Up and Wish List for the draw
• Treat Bag Tags for party favors on reveal night
• Candy Bar Labels to wrap a candy gift
• Best Halloween Candy for what goes in the bag